Put our insurance expertise to work for you.

When you have questions, you want answers. We have created a culture of excellence, where everyone is committed to “customer first” service and focused on anticipating and exceeding your expectations.

If you have questions about insurance policies, billing, claims or just getting started, one of our insurance experts would be happy to assist you. Reach out to us using the contact information below, or send us a message using our online form. We’d love to hear from you.

Stop by our office.
Want to chat with us about your insurance options in person? Visit or contact our Aurora, OH insurance office today!

Our Location

12 South Chillicothe Rd., P.O. Box 271, Aurora, OH 44202-0271

hello@suttoninsurance.com
Phone: 330-562-5145
Fax: 330-562-5146

Get Directions
Sutton Insurance
Directions

Sutton Insurance Agency is conveniently located in the center of Aurora, Ohio on the Southwest corner of Routes 82 & 306. Our office is in the Country Development Building in the heart of Aurora’s beautiful Historic District. There is access to our parking lot from both Route 82 (Garfield Rd.) and Route 306 (Chillicothe Rd.). Please enter the building through the door facing the parking lot, and our offices are on the first floor to your left as you enter. Please drop in any time during office hours! We’d love to meet you and review your insurance needs.

Let’s discuss your insurance.

Complete the form below and one of our insurance experts will be in touch.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We care deeply about providing the best online experience to all visitors. If you need help using our website or have a question about accessibility, contact us and we will be in touch.